Before you move budget on a number, you should know the number is right. CDAI validation is how we show it. We built simulated businesses where the true cost and true revenue of every campaign are known, ran CDAI (Capital, Decision, Accuracy, Intelligence) on them, and compared every figure with the right answer. Then we ran it on HubSpot and Salesforce developer accounts. Here is what we checked and what we found.
Every dollar you move between campaigns rests on a number: what a lead really cost, what a customer really cost, and what a campaign really kept after every cost. If that number is off, the decision built on it is off too. Most dashboards ask you to trust their numbers. CDAI validation is our answer to a fair question from any owner or finance lead: how do you know the math is right?
CDAI works out real profit for each campaign every night, then recommends one of eight decisions: Scale, Hold, Cut, Pause, Quarantine, Renegotiate, Investigate or Flag. You can see how it reaches them in how CDAI works. This page covers the other half: the evidence that the calculations underneath those decisions hold up.
Owners who run on leads and closed deals care about this more than anyone, because the costs the ad platforms cannot see, such as partner payouts, refunds, chargebacks and compliance, are exactly the costs that turn a good-looking campaign into a loss. Our guides to marketing costs and campaigns that look good and lose money walk through how that happens.
The validation compared three numbers that decide whether a campaign deserves more budget. Each one was recalculated from the known answers and compared with what CDAI stored and reported.
| What was checked | Why it matters to you | Result |
|---|---|---|
| True cost per lead | The real price of a lead once every cost is counted, not just the ad platform’s figure. | Matched the database and the engine |
| True customer acquisition cost | What it really costs to win a customer, so budget follows closed business, not clicks. | Matched the database and the engine |
| Contribution margin | What each campaign keeps after the revenue it closed is set against every cost of winning it. | Matched the database and the engine |
Those are the figures in the contribution margin marketing validation report, and every simulated result is labeled as simulated. We do not blend results into one headline number. Decisions are graded per decision type and per business, so a strong result in one place cannot hide a weak one somewhere else.
Want to see these numbers on your own campaigns? Connect your ad accounts and CRM and CDAI calculates real profit for every campaign each night.
The method behind CDAI validation is simple on purpose, because a check is only worth trusting if you can follow it.
A simulated business is the right place to start because it gives the one thing a live account cannot: the true answer. In a real account nobody knows the exact true cost of a campaign in advance, which is the whole reason the number needs calculating. Once the calculations match the known answers, as they did in this CDAI validation, the same calculations are what run on your data.
Simulated businesses check the math. CRM accounts check the connection. After the simulated runs, CDAI ran on HubSpot and Salesforce developer accounts, which are real accounts of those platforms, so deals, contacts and closed revenue came from a real CRM into the same calculations.
It matters because your closed revenue lives in your CRM. HubSpot documents how its deals API stores deal records, and Salesforce documents its Opportunity object the same way. CDAI reads closed deals from those systems, so a campaign’s revenue is the revenue that actually closed. Our guide to offline conversion tracking explains why closed revenue is the piece most setups miss, and Salesforce campaign influence and the HubSpot ads ROI guide show how each CRM fits.
The same rule holds when a lead cannot be tied to a campaign: CDAI keeps that revenue separate and never forces it into a campaign. A number you can trust is more useful than a number that looks complete.
Every figure in CDAI validation comes from a formula you can read. For each campaign, every night:
Here is where each input comes from, so every number has a home:
| Input | Where it comes from |
|---|---|
| Ad spend | Your connected ad accounts, such as Meta’s Marketing API and the Google Ads API |
| Revenue closed | Your CRM: HubSpot or Salesforce |
| Partner payouts, refunds, chargebacks | The systems that record them, or your uploaded files |
| Compliance and operating costs | Costs you add yourself |
You can try the same math on your own numbers with the ROAS calculator, the true CAC calculator or the contribution margin calculator.
CDAI validation did not stop when the report was written. These safeguards run as part of the engine:
Attribution and analytics tools do a useful job: HubSpot describes its analytics as a way to “measure the performance of all your marketing campaigns in one place.” Improvado reviews many of the tools in this space. They are built to show which channel gets credit. CDAI validation backs a different job: CDAI is built to show what each campaign kept after every cost and what to do next, so the two work well together.
If you are comparing options, see Triple Whale vs Rockerbox vs Allocera, the Northbeam alternative, the Rockerbox alternative and the Dreamdata alternative. For a worked look at one account, read the cost per customer Meta ads case study and the true cost per lead case study.
Not ready yet? Keep reading in the guides to average cost per lead, lead quality and the true marketing ROI, or learn about Allocera Intelligence. Industry guides cover HVAC customer acquisition cost, the true cost of a closed install and reconciling financing. All our writing is on the blog.
CDAI validation is the reason the numbers behind your decisions can be trusted. Connect your accounts and see what every campaign really made.
Questions first? Send us a note and we’ll get back to you. Ask about a free distortion audit, pricing or getting started.
We’ll review your submission and reach out within 24 hours.